Project Binnendijk - The Benny

Project Binnendijk - Updates
Land based research 2007

 

Extract from a "Risdon Beazley" salvage report

 

Binnendijk 39 10 08 - 50 32 07 N 02 20 W
- Swept 15.8 meter wreck in 22m
4.75' off Portland Bill. East of Portland in cable area, range still
in use [since closed], get permission from QHM. 4 hours of strong tide From NE in
12.5 hours, approximately from HW Dover to HW + 4. Otherwise OK.
FD Dispersed since 1952
100t Cu No2 LH not touched? Risdon Beazley removed 196t Cu wire & bar? & Ni 1952
19.8.94 224,154lbs wire bars = 1000 @ 224lbs. Randsfjord
203 lbs each. centre of No 2 say 100' from bow, 300' from stern
DEB steel cargo. no quantities sighted.
Last survey revealed wreckage over area 120m x 30m with
main body 070/250 height 3m.

 

The extract helps us to understand why Risdon destroyed the Binnendijk salvaging the hundreds of tons of copper from her holds. Risdon would have used the techniques he learnt as a young lad from an Italian salvage company, where by thin strips of explosive are laid down the seams of the ship and ignited. This caused the ships bulkheads and walls to fall out wards exposing the cargo in her holds to giant cranes lowered from tending barges above.

Looking at copper prices on the US index for around the time gives a good indication of the profit the company stood to make.  

Year

$ per lbs

1950

21.58

1951

24.50

1952

24.50

1953

29.05

1954

29.94

1955

37.51

  Copper price have continued to  increase to the present day. So the Binnendijk is still a site of interest to  salvage companies today. A company in Lyme Bay applied for a permit in 1994. Gleaner have survey the site twice.

 

 

 

 

 

http://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/copper/240798.pdf

Findings from
the translation

(08.11.2006)

This “verdict” from the Dutch council firstly confirms the report we had from the Liverpool Daily Post on the 9th of October 1939. Points such as the way the Binnendijk sank slowly on flames were confirmed along with the fact that all 41 crew members were saved. The verdict also confirmed the current research such as the build place, type of vessel and last route of the Binnendijk were all correct.

The council’s findings did shed some new light on our quest though!! We now know that an English marine ship called “Victoria” came to the aid of the Binnendijk, and not only saved all 41 crew, but tended to the two wounded and also stayed by the Binnendijk (on the request of the Captain) until she slipped beneath the waves.

William Moree’s account also tells us that more than one explosion occurred. The council’s findings agree with us that the most likely cause of the explosion was a mine. Couple this with the fact that we know the U26 had laid a total of 18 mines in the area during September, it now seems certain the Binnedijk was sunk by a mine. However, the Captain does state adamantly that the cargo could not have caused the further explosions! Were there more mines? Was it contraband; had the initial mine not exploded completely on first impact? After all, magnetic mines laid from U-Boats were new inventions during this period. I think we can be sure to rule out anything inside the vessel exploding due to the lack of damage to decks, hatches and as the ships plating was pressed inwards.

The translation has also shed new light on the epic efforts by the Captain, first helmsman, chief engineer, second helmsman and second engineer to save the dying ship, but by a stroke of bad luck – the loss of all steam forced them to abandon the ship with no hope of getting her into Weymouth.

The findings have also allowed us to determine what kind of mine sank the Binnendijk – TMA 28 were some of the earlier magnetic influence mines carried by U-Boats. We know these were carried by the U26 along with torpedoes, but the report rules out a torpedo attack. Read Full Translation.


The schematics of the slightly later TMB 33 mines. This drawing is from the Admiralty after capturing a mine in the Bristol Channel.

Dutch Report (18.10.2006)
We have the actual report in dutch from the Captain of the Binnendijk given at the inquest of her sinking. Many thanks to Harry van Seumeren the son of the Chief Engineer who came to visit us in 2006 for this and other new information about the Benny. If you want to have a go CLICK HERE for the full report.

Land based research 2006


MDD links up with son of Binnendijk crew member
In 2006, Harry van Seumeren came to visit Portland and the team; Harry is the son of Han van Seumeren who was the second engineer on the Benny when it was sunk.

See link on the right for the article from the Echo....

Sketch and dive report by Joao
Sketch and dive report courtesy of Joao Delgado, dive carried out on Sunday 17th July.

Bottom time: 20 mins.

Viz: 'excellent'.

The viz was excellent (I had never had it so good at the Benni). With the project in mind, I decided to produce a rough drawing during the dive.The BT was only about 20 min, so I could not cover a large area. Nevertheless, it was amazing to notice 3 boilers (?) half buried whilst still going down the shot line. To the right of these, there is a big "box" (bigger than each of the boilers). Past the boilers, there are a number of metal beams and debris (with a couple of tyres amongst them). A bit further, there is a long pipe in a diagonal position. To the left of the pipe, there are several metal shells. One of these has got a kind of arch / square structure cut into it.

Sketch by Carey and dive report by Dom and Carey 14th June

 

14th June 2005

courtesy:
Dom & Carey

 

 

 

Visiting Portland’s Breakwater Diving Centre from France where we both live. Dominique Samuel a Breton Diver, Life-boatman at the Arzon station in southern Brittany positioned at Port Crouesty, and I, a former habitué of Breakwater Divers, now living in France, had the chance to slip an extra dive in early one morning. We selected the Binnedijk as it was the closest wreck to the pier now that the ‘Hood’ is a banned ship.
This Old Dutch ship built in the traditional style in 1921 was sunk in October 1939 as a result of a string of 18 U boat mines left by the U26. 18 mines sunk 3 ships with another ship hit but not sunk, a good score for a month’s cruise. The broken ship now lies at approximately 50°32’N W 02 20’ in 28 M with a height off the bottom of approximately 3M. We left the pier at 08:30 on a perfect morning, no clouds, but force 4 rising from W by S. By 09:00 we were on site in a lumpy sea.
Jay shot the wreck and we jumped in - down the shot. He’d had some doubts exactly where the shot was? It was OK - beautifully positioned. Even from the shot it was obvious that we had hit a day of incredible viz.  From 15M down we could see the shapes below not clearly but enough to see them. On the bottom the viz horizontally was greater than 20M, just amazing! We tied off our line though it could be said to be unnecessary, good habits die hard. Our shot was just off boiler 1 (see the diagram) in a mass of pipes and a couple of large bent pipes like ventilators, see picture (  ) we did a thorough inspection of boiler 1, there is a big hole in the side you can look in to the interior but you’ll need a torch to see the tubes inside.  Between boiler 1 and 2 there is a confusion of pipes plates and bit and pieces, again an interesting insight as to how things were constructed in those days, lots of rivets. We moved on to a large round object with a grid in it, under the opening a giant lobster whose tail I could see through the grid but I could not get my hand through to get him out in the open, so that Dom could photo him better, he got a shot head on but not his size. Cuckoo Wrasse and Ling Pout and lots of fish surrounded the wreck. Not that many lines but at least one trawl net on the outer perimeter. The mast had an enlargement on it, you can see those in the old photo. The bow? Section seemed to be semi intact with what we thought was the winch a more detailed inspection will reveal if we were correct.
By now we had been down at 27M or so for 20 minutes so a return to the shot was indicated. Dom’s computer was indicating a minute or so before a compulsory decompression stop and mine was still not into the cautions zone, following good practice we took the details from his computer and stopped 2 minutes at 6 M.  We could see the rippling surface and wave patterns very clearly - like a giant modern painting. On surfacing there was much more wind and a good sea running as we were clear NE of the Bill. On reflection a few hours after the dive, it was impressive we were perhaps lucky to be the only two on the site, but to dive in such conditions a site with such history and so close to harbour was a delight rarely found. We even repositioned the shot for Jay so that it would pull out easily for him. Diving as we do in Southern Brittany with the gulf of Morbihan and the off shore islands of Hoedic, Houat, and Belle Isle not far away we have a good appreciation of picturesque sites, wrecks like this are gems to us and are to you; Hopefully our chance to see more of the site than usual will have contributed an international view to your plan of the site. What a super idea to adopt a wreck. I am expecting the “I’ve dived the BINNEDIJK” tee shirt to be the latest craze for the international set!

Carey Nason & Dominique Samuel. At Castletown, Portland 2005/06/14

Land based research 2005

Built in N V Werf De Noord @ Alblasserdam, by a sub-company of the ship building tycoon Bonn & Mees during 1921, as part of a large order from the Holland and America line.  Shortly after finishing this order Bonn & Mees were forced into liquidation by trade union strikes. She was a type “B” class 6,800 ton, single screw 3000 shaft horse power steam turbine, with double reduction gearing and a service speed of 12 ¼ knots, length of 121.9 metres, beam of 16.5 metres and a draught of 11.3 metres. She was designed as a cargo ship.
The Binnendijk also had seven sister ships: Bilderdijk – torpedoed by a sub on 19/10/1940 sailing from Halifax to Liverpool, Burgerdijk, Blydendijk, Bloommersdijk, Breedijk, Boschdijk, Beemsterdijk - hit a mine off Pembrokeshire in 1941, 40 lives lost.
The Last Voyage
The Binnendijk set off from Boston under steam to New York during September 1939, she was bound for Rotterdam. On entry to the English Channel, she was requested by the Royal Navy to dock in Weymouth or Portland before crossing the channel for an inspection (there was suspicion of her carrying contraband). On the 7/10/1939 as she travelled up to Portland, the captain – W.Moree requested she drop anchor of the Shambles as the sun was setting. Around 10pm she struck a newly developed German magnetic mine. One of the first types used in combat. She was soon ablaze and sinking slowly.
From the Liverpool Daily Post, Oct 9th 1939:
The Dutch steamer BINNENDIJK, 6,800tons, bound from New York to Amsterdam was sunk in the English Channel early yesterday, 41 survivors landed in a lifeboat which stood by all night. Capt W. MOREE of Rotterdam, master of the BINNENDIJK, said, he was on the bridge when there was a terrific explosion, and the engines and wireless were put out of action. “The ship began to sink very slowly.” He said “and when we fired rocket signals they were answered... Later an examination vessel came alongside and making fast to our ship, took us off. There were 41 officers and crew we had no passengers.”
Around 2.40 am on the 8th of October 1939 she slipped beneath the waves for ever lost, or so all aboard thought!! The mine was laid by the U26, under the command of Klaus Ewerth. During the 4 weeks spent on patrol the U26 laid 18 mines and sunk 3 ships. The Alex Van Opstel and the Elena  R being the other two. The Binnendijk now lies 2.4 miles north east of the Shambles in 27 metres of water. Position 50.32.117N   002.20.000W, her wreck number is 18616

Activity since she sunk
16/10/39 – Cable swept by the Kilmun to a depth of 26m off the sea bed. Masts swept off and a buoy laid to warn other ships
21/01/47 – Drift swept by the Steepholm to a depth of 12m off the sea bed. Buoy removed
08/08/52 – Salvaged by Risdon Beazley Ltd. Left 6m off the sea bed
14/01/91 – Examined using a transponder. Found 6m off the sea bed. Main wreckage dimensions 120m X 30m, with smaller scattered wreckage within 60m of the main site.
23/08/05 – MDD team descends to explore and survey the site.


BINNENDIJK
tons 6,873
type Steam Freighter
dimensions Length = 121.9 metres. Beam = 16.5 metres. Draught = 11.3 metres
nationality   NL (Dutch)
built 1921
company NEDERLANDSCHE-AMERIKAANSCHE STOOVAART
voyage BOSTON and NEW YORK for ROTTERDAM
cargo 1000 tons general cargo and oil
attacker U 26
date 07.10.1939 mined - 08.10.1939 sunk
fate mined
square reported   BF3145
position 2.5 miles SE SHAMBLES LV
last Latitude 50 32’.117 N Longitude = 002 20’.000 W


Built by W. de Noord with a length of 416 feet and a beam of 54 feet it had a single screw with 3,000 shaft horse power, steam turbine with double reduction gearing with a service speed of 12+ Knt.


 The Binnendijk during launch.



Binnendijk plan - click for larger image


Officers of the Benny; Han (Harry's father) is third from the right

Click here for Binnendijk photos with highlights




                  Underwater Photos © Izzy Imset 2005